Suspect Judges
This page highlights judges who have been subject to repeated complaints to the Probate Trap and other guardianship advocacy and reform groups, media reporting, court records, or other publicly available information.
There are judges who approve guardianships without the strong evidence that should be required to deprive individuals of their civil rights. There are judges who act in guardianship cases without due process; act without jurisdiction; award high fees to the professional guardians and lawyers who regularly appear before them; and replace family guardians with professional guardians without sufficient justification. They also override alternatives to guardianship, including durable powers of attorney, medical powers of attorney, and family trusts; exclude family members from guardianship proceedings; and are fail to seriously listen to people subject to guardianship and their family members.
If you know of other problematic cases involving the judges on this page, or other judges whom you think should be added, please contact us.
Our initial judge to highlight is Denver County Probate Judge Elizabeth Leith. Judge Leith is the sole judge on the Denver Probate Court. She is up for renomination in 2026 for another six-year term. The Probate Trap opposes renomination and, in May 2026, participated in delivering to Governor Jared Polis a substantial list of statements about Judge Leith in support of that opposition.
Judge Elizabeth Leith, Denver Probate Court, Denver, Colorado
Judge Elizabeth Leith, Denver Probate Court
Judge Leith was appointed in 2011 in response to concerns about her predecessors being too closely connected to guardianship professionals. Unfortunately, Judge Leith’s actions in the 15 years since she was appointed have been problematic.
Serious concerns about her actions are documented in two interviews conducted by the Probate Trap; a set of 14 statements about Judge Leith that the Probate Trap submitted to Colorado Governor Jared Polis; 7 news stories about Judge Leith; a detailed judicial ethics complaint filed against her in 2025; and in a petition we circulated against her renomination.
Because adult guardianship records are sealed in Colorado, public information provides only a partial picture of the underlying proceedings. The stories documented in our submission to Governor Polis represent, in all likelihood, only a fraction of the full story.
Judge Leith is up for renomination this year. Colorado has an overall Judicial Review Commission and subcommissions for each judicial district; the Second District Commission handles Denver County. Unfortunately, both the main commission and the Second District Commission are moral cowards. Neither was interested in seriously asking whether Judge Leith deserve renomination. Our failed efforts to contact both commissions, meet with them, and discuss our concerns. are documented below. Both commissions had a job to do, and failed.
Probate Trap Interviews
Collected Statements
News stories about Judge Leith
Petition to Remove Judge Leith
Efforts to Contact Colorado Judicial Performance Commission
We wrote in June 2026 to each individual member of the Commission. An example letter.
None responded. Commission director Kent Wagner wrote back to us, and basically blew us off. It wasn’t their job to evaluate Judge Leith. Any complaints received after April 1 were untimely and would be ignored. And we should stop writing to the Commission members individually.
We wrote again to Mr. Wagner. He did not reply
Efforts to Contact Second District Commission
We wrote to the individual commission members, including the chair, Kendra Beckwith, four times, each time attaching information about Judge Leith and offering to meet. No member ever responded.”
June 27, 2026, letter
July 21, 2026, letter
August 11, 2026, letter
September 22, 2026, letter
Probate reform blogger and advocate Bret Darken wrote to the Commisson members on July 27, 2026. No member responded.
